Sunday, October 23, 2011
Boardwalk Empire No. 17: Gimcrack & Bunkum
BLOGGER'S NOTE: This recap contains spoilers, so if you haven't seen the episode yet, move along.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/21064/21064a79ab9dd6c4ddd7c11e3cca9019bf7a919e" alt=""
By Edward Copeland
The best discovery in the first season of Boardwalk Empire was Jack Huston, grandson of the great director John Huston, in the role of the fascinating character of physically and mentally disfigured WWI veteran Richard Harrow. I, as I expect many other fans of the show also were, was quite pleased to see Huston's name bumped up to the opening credits when the show returned for its second season. Since the large canvas of characters seems to be multiplying at an exponential rate, it's difficult for all the regulars to get standout moments. Until last week, when Harrow had his monologue about his twin sister while posing for Angela, Richard hadn't been given much to do yet this season. This week's episode builds on last week's showcase for Huston by giving him an unusual, standalone thread that almost plays like a short story except that it is intercut with the other storylines. It's quite good and, as always, Huston excels. The episode itself turns out to be a fast-moving and eventful one outside of Harrow's lovely, pastoral passages and runs a bit shorter than most episodes. It's an entertaining hour with a moving story plopped within it. In fact, despite a shorter running time, the events make the recap run longer. I didn’t want to split it in two again, so I’ve decide to only separate Richard’s story. Something odd about this outing though is the absence of expected repercussions from things set up last week that you’d think would need to be dealt with immediately.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b66d8/b66d8863a3dc1ad667a371af85536406b0adc162" alt=""
We can hear Nucky's amplified voice as the episode begins, but we can't see him. At first, we get a high shot watching cars drive down the beach road to attend a Memorial Day ceremony. In the distance, we can even spot the famous Lucy the Elephant building that Agent Van Alden told his wife about during her visit. "Atlantic City was built for good times, so folks could leave
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4cc3e/4cc3eb0ab16819be0e7289fc28eb6e3dd6627350" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/64a91/64a91ec0f5392ac50af2853e12502c3ab93bd8a0" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/09b95/09b9580e25f328d713fe0f7ee85642e65996a9cb" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3fdfe/3fdfe5f6f1d7757458ede413fd17ec65b7357e9a" alt=""
With the list of the fallen on the podium in front of him, Jimmy's left hand shakes. For a moment, it looks as if he will blow his moment and be unable to speak in public, even looking around as if for help or a prompter. Finally, Darmody finds his voice. "Mr. Thompson just said some impressive things about me, but they're not true. I'm no one's idea of a hero, least of all mine," Jimmy tells the crowd. "When people ask me what I did over there, what I tell them is, 'I made it back.'" As he goes on, he becomes more assured and confident in his manner, but not at the cost of losing his humility. Nucky looks quite annoyed that Jimmy isn't falling on his face. "We fought for the idea that democracy was worth saving. We fought for our mothers, for our sons, for our wives. We fought for America. I believe it was worth it. The audience that had sat and stood in respectful silence so far as Jimmy spoke broke out in equally respectful applause. Bader claps, making Nucky sitting next to him on stage feel he must as well though he glares as he does. Jimmy holds up the list of those killed from the area. "This is a list of brave men." He begins reading the alphabetical list of those killed in action. When he gets to one name, he says, "I knew Les." He continues making his way through the reading of the names. Beginning with the next scene, the story of Richard's daylong excursion begins with the sound of Jimmy's reading able to be heard through the window of his room. If you wish, you can go read his day now by clicking here. Except for the final two scenes, it doesn't relate to any of the other storylines. Personally, I think the best approach is to read this whole entry first until it gets to the moment when Richard's story does cross back over and I'll include the link again, then cross back for the finish here.
"Hear him up there — all for democracy. What a load of bull," Nucky rules on Jimmy's speech as he changes clothes for golf with Harry Daugherty and Daugherty's longtime friend and aide without a title, Jess Smith (Ed Jewett). Nucky keeps rambling about Jimmy, saying he enlisted because he couldn't hack it at Princeton after Thompson pulled strings to get him in the university, but Daugherty's attention focuses as much on Nucky's words now as they did during that phone call seeking help when Harry paid more attention to where boxes needed to go in his White House office. Daugherty finally realizes that Nucky isn't going to stop talking on the subject so he tells Thompson that he and Smith are only there for the day. "It's a holiday — how about we play some golf?" Harry suggests. "Am I boring you, Harry?" Nucky asks. Daugherty lets Thompson know that he's gone out of his way to help him with his legal problems, picking from a list of possible federal prosecutors, though Smith must remind him of the man's name. "Charles Kenneth Thorogood," Smith says. "He's someone you can work with," Daugherty insists. "You actually enjoy golfing?" Nucky asks. "I enjoy being a man with the time to play it," Daugherty smiles as he heads to the course. As Nucky continues lacing his golf shoes, Smith approaches him. "I hear you're acquainted with Mr. George Remus," Smith says. "I'm acquainted with a lot of people," Nucky replies. Smith tells Nucky that he'll be meeting him in Cincinnati on Wednesday and wonders if Thompson considers him a reliable businessman. "I'd consider him a major bootlegger," Nucky responds. "That would be the business I'm talking about. Perhaps you could put in a word — let him know I don't bite," Smith requests.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4ec9e/4ec9e0a41729045b8cee3baa39cf33ada17415c9" alt=""
The six old cronies of the Commodore have summoned Jimmy and Eli to see them at the estate of one of them, Jackson Parkhurst, to find out what's going on since they've financed the coup on Nucky to the tune of $70,000, none of them have been able to speak with the Commodore and the bombing took out the warehouse and all that liquor. (This seems the appropriate time to mention one of the events that occurred last week that doesn't get updated in this episode. Agent Clarkson got severely burned in that explosion, but his injury
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3e97d/3e97d5f2b67fd4a543cf852f12537766be2e5487" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b6fe4/b6fe42666ee3ea7f8b1cf5d43276393a809d43e6" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a9234/a9234de6c31bba01085b02cc9fe9f5edd7a198c2" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4e1f3/4e1f324b8abaff8573cc88378d58da892725d153" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/34093/34093e45adbce8e56782cb8211bc3da42d06a6cf" alt=""
Jimmy lets Gillian tend to his wound from Parkhurst's cane as he shares with her how the meeting with the old moneymen went. "What did they say about your father?" Gillian asks her son. "They know something's wrong," Jimmy tells her. "They questioned you, berated you and then Jackson — " Jimmy interrupts his mother. "You know Parkhurst?" Gillian informs Jimmy that she knows all of them. "How well?" Jimmy wants to know. His mother ducks that question and instead says, "No one is allowed to do this to you." He reminds her that it's $70,000 that they are talking about. "That's nothing to men like that," Gillian tells him. "Plus Horvitz in Philly" keeps bugging him about his booze, Jimmy adds. Again, that's the only mention of Manny Horvitz this week, when last week he told Jimmy that people who tried to screw him over ended up cut into little pieces and put in his freezer. "You will not be disrespected and you have to make that clear," Gillian declares. "Alright, ma," Jimmy says as if he's surrendering to her. "Alright leave me alone or alright I understand what needs to be done?" she asks. Jimmy closes his eyes for a moment then re-opens them and tells her, "Both." Gillian pats him on his cheek. "John D. Rockefeller was born on a farm. His father was a bigamist and a confidence man. His mother was a saint. Now he's worth $1 billion," Gillian shares then puffs on her cigarette. "And how is he spending his Memorial Day?" Jimmy asks. "He's not pumping oil," Gillian replies, placing her cigarette in Jimmy's mouth.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a2354/a23545fcf16baf196e426235019f90124e934580" alt=""
Nucky comes home complaining about how much sun he got playing golf and how it makes him look like a lobster when Margaret asks him in a whisper, "Where is Owen?" "He's dropping off Harry Daugherty, why?" Nucky responds. "Your brother's here — in the conservatory," she informs him. This season, ever since Nucky and Margaret moved to the new place in Margaret, I've been referring to the part of their house with an inside greenhouse as "the covered garden" or similar names. Margaret threw me by calling it a conservatory since, having played the game Clue since a kid, I always thought a conservatory was a music room. It seems the word does also have a musical definition, but mainly as a school of music and while the Clue card I played with as a child showed a sheet of music, later editions changed it to match the meaning Margaret uses. "You let him in?" Nucky says surprised. "What else could I do?" Margaret asks him. An exasperated Nucky sighs, "Fine" and stomps into the conservatory where Eli stands with his back to him, admiring the scenery. "How many places have you lived in — since you moved out of the house?" Eli inquires. "Eight, nine — what difference does it make?" Nucky answers. "I had the upstairs apartment on Monroe, the bungalow with June and the place we've got now," Eli says. Nucky reminds Eli that he was there for Christmas. "The last time we spoke, there was an offer made," Eli brings up as softly and humbly as he can. "The offer's gone," Nucky declares coldly. "See, that's it," Eli says, making slicing motions with his hands in the air accompanied by sounds with his mouth. "No conversation. Only orders. I'm your brother, Nucky." Nucky's expression remains distant and unsympathetic, even as he tells Eli, "Then I
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/63bb9/63bb97d27ef9045baae5c6b6117dceefe109d6d7" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/25cea/25ceac29dc6415f9af8704ea49bfa86c3789d558" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0a092/0a0928f708ec39ce1ccf902a95c1781b7bd9d051" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/21c52/21c52518f3c271fb16749a2fd183ed09fdca2a88" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/92f23/92f2378b007b8620aa7369e2030d61b7f2db8381" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/451a8/451a80f86a07e53e36fce60474311aa2491a4376" alt=""
After Nucky has changed clothes and put himself together more formally, he returns to the Ritz. "Sorry to keep you boys waiting," he apologizes to Daugherty, Jess Smith, Ginsburg and another man. Daugherty asks if he's been crawling through the underbrush because of the way Thompson's face looks. "Too much sun this morning," Nucky says. "Say hello to your new prosecutor," Harry announces as the man (T.J. Kenneally) shakes Nucky's hand. "You must be Charles," Nucky declares. "Call me Chip, Mr, Thompson," Thorogood requests. "Chip, Harry tells me you're a man I can count on," Nucky tells his "prosecutor."I'd certainly like to think so," Chip replies. "Have you talked?" Nucky asks, addressing his lawyer, Ginsburg. "Mr. Thorogood and I have begun a discussion. He's fairly new to the courtroom," Ginsburg informs his client. "I hope that's not going to be an issue," Thorogood says. "Only if you don't know where the judge sits," Daugherty smiles. "He's the one in the robe, right?" Thorogood jokes. Nucky asks how it's going to work and Ginsburg explains that the U.S. Attorney — Thorogood in this case — presents a motion to transfer to federal court. "Under the argument that the election rigging charges and the Mann Act violations constitute an ongoing criminal enterprise operating across state lines," Chip adds. Which places it under the jurisdiction of the 3rd Circuit, Ginsburg continues, "We go before our judge. He buys the humble wares which we set before him and Mr. Thorogood brings all his legal acumen and youthful energy to bear." Smith joins in, telling Nucky that the Justice Department then decides that it isn't worth the time or resources to prosecute the case and drop it. "We're swamped with Volstead as it is," Harry says while he and every lawyer in the room holds a drink in his hand. Nucky still looks nervous. "You're not saying thank you," Daugherty points out. "I need a guarantee," Nucky insists. Harry tells him that he's not going to get one. "Just remember — this was your idea," Nucky reminds Ginsburg. Nucky's lawyer excuses himself for an early train while the D.C. visitors have a free evening and seek a night's entertainment.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6bd34/6bd3472b01ab209ddddebdee81ea55d3df77645e" alt=""
Eli has in his hand what appears to be the chamber for a gun, but it must be a toy one because his young son Brian (Brandon Zumsteg) says, "You can fix it, right?" Eli tells him, "Your old pop can fix anything" and takes a drink from his flask. Brian asks his dad if his throat is sore and Eli tells him that what he drank is medicine when there's a loud knock on the garage door. "I'm not eating, June," Eli shouts. "Eli, it's George. Can I talk with you," Ward Boss O'Neill calls from outside. Eli nods at Brian to let him in. "Hello there, Patrick," O'Neill greets the boy. "I'm Brian," he corrects him. O'Neill says, "Sure, OK" and pats the lad on the head. Eli tells Brian that what they need to fix his toy six shooter is a “veeblefetzer. The left-handed kind.” He sends the boy across the street to Mr. Dean's to see if he might have one. Brian runs off and George comes closer so he and Eli can talk. "We're alone, right?" O'Neill asks. "What's it look like?" Eli answers. "I don't know," an anxious-sounding O'Neill responds. "You gotta lot of kids." Eli tells him that he doesn't store them in the garage. "There's a rumor — going around — the Commodore, you know?" O'Neill spits out as if he's out of breath. ""I don't know," Eli responds after taking another big drink from his flask. "That he apoplexied — that he's
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1d62a/1d62acd2b8dd330d3e5aba79d723466c3287cd33" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/027f8/027f816c74adc633998c66c630e325d611a9706c" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/98687/9868775771d202ccfc7454cd366f1c4da4a92914" alt=""
Jimmy and Angela sit at their table. She asks how his head is feeling. "Like I went another round with that car door," he replies. "You need to pay more attention," Angela says, obviously not knowing the true source of the injury. "That's why it's called an accident, Ange," he tells her. "The things you said at the ceremony — did you mean them?" Angela inquires. "I'm here — with you. My son's asleep in his bed. Nobody's hungry, nobody's scared. What else is there?" Jimmy answers her. "There's gotta be something. Hasn't there?" Angela says. Jimmy gets up from his seat and walks to his wife. He strokes her hair and plants a kiss on her lips, her forehead and her nose when someone knocks at the door. This would be the ideal time to click over to Richard's story since that's where this scene will conclude.
A scream awakes Margaret who gets out of bed to investigate. She looks in on Teddy and Emily, who both sleep soundly. When she turns around after closing their bedroom door, she jumps. "Jesus, Mary and Joseph!" Margaret exclaims, but it's only Katy. "Did you hear something too?" she asks the maid. "What do you mean?" Katy replies. "Someone screaming," Margaret explains. "No, I heard you out here," Katy says. Katy asks Margaret if there is something wrong. "The children are fine. It's been a strange day. You should get back to bed," Margaret tells her. Katy bid her goodnight and returns to her room, but Margaret watches her closely. When Katy opens her bedroom door and goes inside, we see Owen shirtless in her bed. "Keep your voice down," Katy whispers. "It wasn't me who screamed," Owen reminds her. "Couldn't help it," Katy coos. "Well, I'm up to it again if that's what you prefer," Sleater offers. "She's out there snoopin' around. Probably thinks I’m pinching the silverware. I should, too, what she pays me,” Katy complains about Margaret. “Tight with a pound, is she?” Owen asks. "That's just the tip of it. She made me call her family in New York and they didn't want anything to do with her," Katy gossips. "Hard luck," Sleater shrugs. Katy tells him that he shouldn't be in her room at this hour to which Owen responds that he shouldn't be in there at all since Nucky senses when something is even half wrong. Katy disrobes anyway and pleads for him not to get her into trouble. "I'd never dare," Owen promises.
Eli takes Deputy Halloran (Adam Nucci) into the garage where O'Neill's corpse still resides. We haven't seen Halloran since last season when he was elected sheriff and served for about a minute before Nucky put Eli back in the job once the votes were cast. "I can't see anything, Eli," Halloran says about the dark garage. Eli asks Halloran what he needs to see. "Whatever it is I'm doing," he answers. Even in the dark with just Eli holding a flashlight, Halloran can figure out quickly Eli called for body disposal help. "Jesus, is it somebody I know?" Halloran whines. "It's Mary Pickford," Eli tells him. "You killed Mary Pickford?" Halloran asks both with surprise and a tone in his voice that makes you think he considers that could be an actual possibility. "Help me get this in the car, then you can go," Eli says. The two men haul the covered body of the former ward boss out of Eli's garage.
Nucky tries to work at a desk while Eddie dozes in a chair. Music from revelry in an adjoining room drifts in but grows louder as the door opens. "Eddie, right?" Thorogood, stripped to his undershirt and boxers with a hooker hanging on him asks. "Yeah," Eddie answers. Chip asks for cold champagne, ice water and oysters. As he moves from view, we can see Daugherty being serviced in a chair and Jess Smith dancing around in the back. Eddie complies and Chip returns to the party. "Shut the door, counselor," Nucky says. His prosecutor returns and does what he's told.
Crickets sing as Eli digs a hole on the side of a road near a field, George O'Neill's lifeless body on the ground next to him. The hole finished, he drags O'Neill to the hole and starts the process of burying him. Accompanying him on the soundtrack is the "Slow March" from Gaetano Donizetti's opera Belisario which continues through the credits. The piece was used in one of the rare Confederate Civil War brass band compositions A Storm in the Land. This version was arranged by Rob Morseberger.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7b198/7b1985df3d2792c920633163fbbe063492d38458" alt=""
Tweet
Labels: Boardwalk Empire, HBO, Huston, The Sopranos, TV Recap
Comments:
<< Home
"Jack Huston, grandson of the great director John Huston, in the role of the fascinating character of physically and mentally disfigured WWI veteran Richard Harrow."
And great grandson of marvelous character actor Walter Huston.
And great grandson of marvelous character actor Walter Huston.
True. Also son of Oscar-nominated screenwriter Tony Huston and nephew of the great Oscar-winning actress Anjelica Huston. If I listed his whole family tree, the sentence would go on forever (and I'm doing him a favor by not mentioning his uncle Danny who can't act his way out of a paper bag yet still gets work).
Just noting the fact because this particular apple didn't fall far from that old tree.
I don't actually much care about JH's pedigree except for that one thing- am a huge Walter Huston fan.
I don't actually much care about JH's pedigree except for that one thing- am a huge Walter Huston fan.
Me too. Of course John wasn't just a great director and writer. He did some great acting himself as well. I don't know how the gene got so screwed up when it came to Danny.
Post a Comment
<< Home